Clopay vs Amarr: Which Garage Door Brand Offers the Best Quality and Value?

When it comes to buying a new garage door, most homeowners want something that looks good, lasts long, and gives real value for their money. Yet, with so many choices, how do you know which garage door brand is best? Two of the biggest names homeowners often compare are Clopay and Amarr. Both brands are trusted in the industry, but each has its strengths.

At Titan Garage Doors Des Moines, we have worked with both brands, and we know what local homeowners look for—whether you live near Gray’s Lake or the East Village. Let us dive into this garage door comparison so you can pick the right one for your home.

Why Compare Clopay and Amarr Garage Doors?

Not all garage doors are created equal. Just like choosing between two cars, you will find unique features, strengths, and trade-offs. Both Clopay and Amarr have long histories of making quality doors, but the right pick depends on what you value most. So, how do you decide?

Clopay Garage Doors Review: What You Should Know

Clopay is one of the best garage door brands in America. In fact, it is the largest residential garage door manufacturer in the U.S. Made in Ohio, Clopay doors are known for their wide variety of styles and high-quality craftsmanship. Homeowners often love Clopay because they can find almost any style to match their home.

• Range of Products: From traditional raised-panel doors to sleek modern looks, Clopay offers something for every taste. You can even get carriage house doors that look like old barn doors but open with modern convenience.
• Materials Used: They make doors in steel, wood, aluminum, and composite. That means you can choose something budget-friendly or go for a high-end look.
• Insulation: One of Clopay’s biggest selling points is its Intellicore® insulation technology. It keeps your garage warmer in the winter and cooler in the summer—perfect for Des Moines’ changing seasons.
• Customization: Want a custom color or unique window design? Clopay gives you plenty of options.

Overall, Clopay garage doors are known for quality and energy efficiency, making them a great choice if you plan to stay in your home long-term.

Amarr: A Reliable Garage Door Brand

Amarr is another garage door brand that has been around for decades and continues to be a household name across the U.S. Known for its affordability and safety features, Amarr is often the go-to choice for homeowners who want something reliable without breaking the bank.

• Range of Products: Amarr offers a wide selection of styles—classic, modern, and carriage house designs.
• Materials Used: They specialize in steel garage doors, but you can also find wood and composite options.
• Unique Features: Amarr offers Quiet Door® technology, so you don’t wake the neighbors every time you head out early.
• Eco-Friendly Approach: Amarr recycles a large amount of scrap metal and makes efforts to keep production sustainable.

If you’re looking for a dependable and budget-friendly option, Amarr might be the right fit.

Clopay vs Amarr: Garage Door Comparison

So now comes the big question—how do these two garage door brands stack up against each other? Let us break it down by the key factors that matter most.

Design and Style Options

If you care about design, Clopay takes the lead. They have everything from wood-look steel doors to contemporary glass garage doors. If you are someone who wants your home in Sherman Hill or West Des Moines to stand out, Clopay has the edge.

Amarr, on the other hand, focuses more on traditional and modern steel options that still look great but lean toward practical designs. You may not get as many customization choices, but their doors still look great and fit well with traditional and modern homes alike.

Insulation and Energy Efficiency

Living in Iowa means dealing with hot summers and freezing winters. That is why garage door insulation matters in every home.

Clopay offers insulation with high R-values, which helps regulate your garage’s temperature and lowers energy bills. Their polyurethane insulation is especially effective for keeping the cold out in January or the heat out in July.

Amarr also offers insulated options, though many of their models lean toward mid-range efficiency. They are great if you want to find a good mix between comfort and affordability. On the other hand, they might not be as energy-efficient as Clopay’s best models.

Durability and Maintenance

In terms of garage door quality and durability, both Clopay and Amarr deliver solid performance. The main difference is that Clopay’s wood styles, while stunning, often need more upkeep compared to steel or composite.

Amarr doors are generally low-maintenance. Their steel doors come with a tough finish that resists rust and wear, making them a great option for busy homeowners in Des Moines.

Safety Features

Amarr stands out with its SafeGuard pinch protection. It reduces the chance of fingers getting caught. Families with young kids in neighborhoods like Beaverdale or Sherman Hill in Des Moines will appreciate the added safety.

Warranty and Support

Worried about warranties? Both brands have you covered. Clopay tends to offer longer terms, especially on higher-end models, which can make your investment feel even safer. Amarr’s warranties are solid too, just a touch shorter.

Here in Des Moines, it is not difficult to find a garage door installer familiar with both. Our team at Titan Garage Doors Des Moines works with these brands every day and can walk you through the warranty details to make sure you feel confident in your choice.

Price and Value

Let’s talk about cost. If the budget is tight, Amarr offers affordable garage doors without sacrificing reliability. However, if you see your new garage door as a long-term investment, Clopay delivers more value over time.

Which Garage Door Brand Should You Choose?

So, which one is right for you—Clopay or Amarr? The answer depends on your priorities.

• If you want top-notch insulation, design flexibility, and long-term value, Clopay is worth the investment.
• If you are budget-conscious but still want a reliable door with great safety features, Amarr may be the smarter choice.

Think about how you use your garage. Do you spend time working on it during the winter? Do you care most about curb appeal? Or is safety and price your main concern? Answering these questions makes the decision easier.

Want to see how other brands stack up beyond Clopay and Amarr? Check out our guide on 2025’s Best Garage Door Brands: Which One Is Right for You? to compare more options and find your perfect fit.

Need Garage Door Installation Near Me?

At the end of the day, the best garage door brand for you comes down to your budget, style, and priorities. If you’re thinking about a garage door installation or garage door replacement in Des Moines, IA, our certified team is ready to help. At Titan Garage Doors Des Moines, we’ve worked with both Clopay and Amarr doors all across the metro, and we know what works best for local homes.

Our team is here to explain your options, clear up any questions, and make sure your new garage door looks great and keeps your Des Moines home safe. Ready for a change? Call us now at (515) 650-6850 and ask about our flexible monthly payment plans. Let’s get you the perfect garage door without the stress.